So, time for the rematch. Clausewitz decided to take the Emperor's finest this time to face the Tau. Definitely a different game!

Rules Used

Core rules with 2008 errata/faq.
Tau 5.1

Armies.

Tau

Fire Warriors + Ethereal + Devil + Skyray
Scorpionfish
Kroot
Fire Warriors
Kroot
Stingrays + Stingrays + Skyray
Crisis + Shas'O
Broadside
Barracuda
Orca
Orca
Hero

Marines

Tactical + SC
Tactical + Hunter + 2 Razorbacks
Warhound Titan
Warhound Titan
Terminators + Chaplain
Terminators + Captain
Whirlwinds + Hunter
Scouts
Thunderbolts
Thunderbolts

Deployment.

The marines don't garrison any formations
The broadsides garrison the western edge objective and the white fire warriors garrison the blitz, both on overwatch.
Both kroot climb into orca's and the Hero is scheduled for turn one.
Remaining deployment as shown.
Photobucket

Turn One.

No teleports

Initiative - Marines

Marines pass the initiative to the Tau
Scorpionfish sets overwatch
T'bolts 1 are put on overwatch after a very direct instruction from the Marine Commander (Reroll)
White firewarriors reset overwatch
T'bolts 2 also go on CAP
The Hero's orbit brings it over the battlefield. It targets both missiles at Warhound 1. Both missiles hit causing 2 points of damage and breaking the war engine that heads forward to the eastern edge of the battlefield
Scouts go on overwatch
Broadsides reset overwatch
Tactical with Razorbacks go on overwatch A pattern is forming here!
Stingrays go on overwatch
SC tactical go on overwatch
In an attempt to break the deadlock the barracuda's are ordered to hit the whirlwinds. T'bolts 1 decide to intercept and between them and two hunters both barracuda's are shot down despite their desperate manoeuvres.
Whirlwinds go on overwatch
Crisis suits march into the central wood
Warhound 2 doubles forward. It unloads all its weapons on the crisis suits destroying two Battlesuit. The remaining two fall back behind the wood.
Orca with brown kroot come in to air assault the broken warhound 1. T'bolts 2 leave cap to attack the flyer. The flyer is damaged but not fatally. 2 kroot are killed but the war engine is destroyed. The kroot consolidate into the buildings
The ethereal firewarriors go on overwatch
White orca stands down

End Phase.

Orca brown leaves with 3 bm. Both t'bolt flights leave with no bm

Rallying

Tau
Pass - Kroot, Shas'O
Fail -
Marines
Pass -
Fail -
Photobucket

Turn Two

No teleports

Initiative - Marines

Warhound 2 advances. It shoots the Kroot, killing one unit
T'bolts 1 go on CAP
Brown Orca is order to ground attack but refuses and stands down
Whirlwinds sustain fire at the brown kroot. 3 are hit killing 2 and breaking them
Broadsides reset overwatch, after some direct communications by the Shas'O (Reroll)
T'bolts 2 attack the Kroot. 2 hits are saved
Firewarriors white reset overwatch
SC Tactical advance. They shoot the kroot but miss
The crisis suits march east into some buildings
Scouts reset overwatch
White orca stands down
Tactical with razorbacks reset overwatch
Tau pass all their remaining activations as they are all on overwatch

End Phase

T'bolts 1 remain on CAP and T'bolts 2 leave with no bm

Rallying

Tau
Pass -
Fail - Brown Kroot
Marines
Pass -
Fail -
Photobucket

Turn Three

Both terminator formations appear in the woods with the broadsides, both arrive with one bm

Initiative - Marines

The terminator captain orders a combined assault on the broadsides. The suits overwatch fire is wild and no damage is scored. All the suits are destroyed in combat for the loss of one terminator unit
The brown orca ground attacks. It flies on to target the whirlwinds. The aa fire is ineffective but the lone hit scored on the artillery is saved
The whirlwinds sustain fire at the brown kroot but can't damage them. One unit is lost for the bm
The stingrays advance and shoot at the terminators with captain. 3 hits can't penetrate the thick armour
Warhound 2 doubles forward. It unloads on the crisis suits wiping them out
White firewarriors go back on overwatch
T'bolts 2 ground attack the brown kroot. No hits are scored
The scorpionfish sustains fire at the commanders terminators. 2 hits again fail to damage the terminators
SC tactical double and shoot the final brown kroot unit into oblivion
Orca white enters the battle to assault the terminators with captain. The marines save the CAP and the assault goes in. One kroot dies for no kills on the terminators. The tau win the roll off by 3 killing one stand finally. The broken terminators retreat away
The tactical with razorbacks double forward
The scouts march after some stern words from the Supreme Commander (reroll)
And the Tau realise they have lost 2-0 as the mech firewarriors can't make it into the marine half!

End Phase

Result - Tau 0 - Marines 2 (They shall not pass, defend the line)
Photobucket